June 30,the biggest day of the year for the nation’s accountants,is fast approaching. It’s also the most important time of year for the nation’s charities. If you’ve ever made a donation to any of them,I bet they sent you a letter in the past few weeks reminding you how good it would be if you did so again ASAP.
Illustration by Simon Letch
But,as we were reminded by a last week,this is likely to be a bad year for charities. Why? Because in a cost-of-living crisis,many of us decide that charity begins at home.
According to polling by academics at the University of Queensland,78 per cent of people have reduced their donations because of the crisis facing their own budgets.
This is particularly bad timing for those charities that help people having trouble affording food and other necessities,such as the Salvos. The demand for their services has jumped for the same reason people are finding it harder to give. (Yes,the Salvos have “reached out” to me lately. And as I did myself in my uniformed youth,they waved a collection box under my nose.)
Perhaps it’s the accountant in me that makes me particularly attracted to donations that are tax-deductible. As everyone soon learns,you can’t make a profit out of tax deductibility. You can only reduce a cost.
But I like it because it lets me send a bit of taxpayers’ money in a direction chosen by me,not the politicians. The pollies mightn’t give a stuff about the wellbeing of refugees and asylum seekers,but I do. And to some small extent,I can make them kick the tin.
Also last week,purely by chance,I’m sure,we were reminded that although Australians like to think of themselves as generous,we’re actually tighter than people in other English-speaking countries. Even the Kiwis are more giving than we are.
Which brings me to my beef about donations. Now,I’ve long been a defender of the Tax Office. It does an important job in making sure we pay as much tax as we should. One reason I got out of accounting was because I decided the only interesting part of it was giving tax advice,but I didn’t want to spend my life helping the well-off avoid doing their duty to the community.
But a few weeks ago,I got a letter from the Tax Office,via the myGov website,naturally,that was the strangest I’ve ever had from them. And it really pee’d me off.
The standard form letter said they’d happened to notice that my claim for donations was a lot higher than other people’s,and they were just wondering whether I might possibly have made some mistake. They hoped I knew you could claim only for donations to outfits that had been awarded tax deductibility. And they hoped I knew I shouldn’t be claiming for any donation for which I couldn’t produce a receipt.
If,on reflection,I realised I had made some terrible “mistake”,I was free to amend my return and thereby,they hinted without saying,avoid possible further investigation and penalty.
But failing that,there was no suggestion I do anything about their veiled accusation except,presumably,sit there shivering,waiting for the taxman’s knock on the door.
It may be true,as coppers always say,that if you’ve done nothing wrong,you’ve got nothing to fear,but that doesn’t stop you resenting an unwarranted insinuation that you’re dishonest.
Ross Gittins was approached for a donation by the Salvation Army.Joe Armao
What gets me is that knowing my claim was large,I would have happily included a detailed list with my return,but the taxman made no provision for me to do so. Nor when he sent his accusatory letter,did he invite me to explain or substantiate my claim.
And I get the feeling that the taxman’s algorithm just found an outsized number and dispatched a letter without further consideration. Did he know that I always make a big claim? Did he allow for the likelihood that people on high incomes can afford to be more generous? Did he note that I’d been a tax agent for many years and so didn’t need reminding of the rules?
Well,I know the taxman doesn’t want to be burdened by any extra information from me,but I’ll give him a heads-up anyway. My claim for this financial year won’t be as big as last year’s,but the one for next year will be a whopper. I’m thinking of setting up a charity of my own. All above board,naturally.
Ross Gittins is the economics editor.
Ross Gittins unpacks the economy in an exclusive subscriber-only newsletter..