Australia, insurance, car, home, live, holidays

Capitalists have managed to ensure that ordinary workers get enough of the spoils to keep them content.Credit:Pat Scala

I remind you of this because,for 30 or 40 years in America,and now about a decade in Australia,the capitalist system – economists prefer calling it the market system – hasn’t been giving ordinary workers enough to keep them getting better off,while the few people at the top of the treehave been doing better,year after year.

If you wonder why so many Americans voted for a man like Donald Trump,and now delude themselves that he didn’t lose the last election,whythe Yanks seem to be rapidly dismantling their democracy,a big part of their discontent is their loss of faith that the economic system is giving them a fair shake.

Fortunately,it’s nothing like that bad in Australia. Not yet,anyway. What’s true is that the average standard of living in Australia today is no better than it was a decade ago – something that hasn’t happened before in the more than 75 years since World War II.

Over the eight years before the pandemic,wages rose barely faster than inflation. We’ve had wage stagnation,now made a lot worse by the supply-chain disruptions of the pandemic,soaring electricity and gas prices caused by Russia’s war,and by the way floods keep wiping out our fruit and vegetable crops.

A wheat crop in Central Victoria is one of the many crops devastated by flooding in south eastern Australia.Credit:Eddie Jim

When Labor went to this year’s federal election promising to “get wages moving”,I think it struck a chord with many voters.

After we ended centralised wage-fixing by the Industrial Relations Commission in the early 1990s,we moved to collective bargaining at the level of the individual enterprise. Workers’ right to strike was hedged about with many requirements and limits.

At the beginning,more than 40 per cent of workers were covered by enterprise agreements. By now,however,some academic experts calculate that the proportion of workers covered byactive agreements is down to about 15 per cent.

At the jobs and skills summit in September,all sides agreed that the enterprise bargaining system had broken down. Last week the government introduced its answer to wage stagnation,the Secure Jobs,Better Pay bill.

Multi-employer bargaining is intended to help strengthen the negotiating position of women in low-paid jobs.Credit:Paul Jones

It would make a host of changes,many of which strengthen existing provisions of the Fair Work Act,and most of which the industrial parties agree would be improvements. It makes job security and gender pay equity explicit goals of the act,prohibits sexual harassment and requirements that workers keep their pay secret,and strengthens the right of workers with family responsibilities to request flexible working hours. More debatably,it abolishes the Australian Building and Construction Commission.

To repair enterprise bargaining,it clarifies the BOOT – better off overall test – requiring that agreements leave no worker worse off. This was the Business Council’s greatest complaint against enterprise agreements.

One reason such agreements now cover so few workers is that they’re expensive and complex for small and middle-size employers to organise. Hence,the proposal to widen the existing provision for “multi-employer bargaining”:workers in similar enterprises allowed to bargain collectively with a number of employers.

This would widen access to enterprise bargaining. It’s aimed particularly at strengthening the bargaining position of women in low-paid jobs in the aged care,childcare and disability care sector.

Ambit claims and exaggerated rhetoric are standard fare in industrial relations,butthe cries of fear and outrage coming from the various employer groups are over the top.

It would “create more complexity,more strikes and higher unemployment,” said one. It was “so fatally flawed” it would “emasculate enterprise bargaining”,according to another outfit. It was “seismic” in its impact,claimed a third.

Methinks they doth … I’d be amazed if they actually believe that stuff. They’re probably still adjusting to the shock of having the unions back in the government tent. They know they won’t be able to stop the bill being passed,so they want at least to be seen opposing it with all their voice.

What changing the law won’t change is that the proportion of workers in a union has fallen from 50 per cent to 14 per cent. The small and middle-size businesses we’re talking about have even fewer union members than that.

No union members,no strike. No strike,no big pay rise. In any case,really powerful unions get big pay riseswithout needing to strike.

This is an attempt to make bargaining provisions that didn’t work last time,work this time. I doubt if these modest changes will do much to “get wages moving” again. More’s the pity. If I’m right,Australia’s capitalism will remain broken.

The Business Briefing newsletter delivers major stories,exclusive coverage and expert opinion.Sign up to get it every weekday morning.

License this article