Steve Johnson,who campaigned for decades to have his brother’s death treated as a homicide and continues to believe it was an anti-gay hate crime,said Thursday’s guilty plea and subsequent conviction “might be the most emotional moment yet” in the 34-year rollercoaster since he learnt Scott’s fate.
It was the second time White had stood before a NSW Supreme Court judge and declared himself responsible for killing Johnson,a 27-year-old gay man whose naked body was found at the bottom of a 60-metre cliff near Manly’s North Head – not far from a gay beat where he used to go “poofter bashing” with mates.
The first time,in January 2022,White surprised his lawyers when he pleaded guilty to murder during a pre-trial hearing before Justice Helen Wilson. In decisions that would later be set aside,Wilson dismissed an application by White’s lawyers to have his plea withdrawn and sentenced him to 12 years’ jail after she was unable to establish beyond reasonable doubt that it was a premeditated anti-gay hate crime.
According to a statement of agreed facts,signed by White,he told witnesses in March 2020 that he used to go “poofter bashing” but was secretly gay,and that he and Johnson went to North Head together after meeting at a Manly pub. He told them he didn’t have sex with Johnson and didn’t know why he took his clothes off,but that the two of them had a “fight” and he swung the first punch before Johnson stumbled and fell off the cliff,the document states.
On Thursday,lengths were taken in the Supreme Court to ensure White fully understood his plea. He was allowed to have his solicitor sit beside him in the dock as he was arraigned,and Justice Robert Beech-Jones asked him directly if he understood that “you are accepting legal responsibility for[Johnson’s] death but not murder”.
“Yeah,I do,” White replied.