In other words,12 winners for every one “loser”. That’s the iron law of arithmetic that Albanese is banking on.
Economics,politics and the original design of stage 3 have got Labor and Albanese to this point.
The economics isthe combination of inflation and interest rates (and more than two years of falling real wages) that is biting across the country. The politics has been Labor’s antipathy to the stage 3 proposal ever since it was unveiled by Scott Morrison in his 2018 budget.
The politics was tied up with the design. While most focus has been onthe sheer weight of cash that will flow to high-income earners under stage 3 (who,as the biggest taxpayers in the country,would always get a substantial benefit),a problem was inserted by Morrison and then exacerbated by Josh Frydenberg.
Loading
This wasthe creation of the low- and middle-income tax offset (the LMITO or so-called Lamington) and its subsequent supersizing by the Morrison government in its bid to cling to power in 2022.
A person earning $65,000,after the $1500 Lamington for the 2021-22 financial year was taken into account,paid $10,092 in personal income tax.
The end of the Lamington last year meant the same person on $65,000 delivered $11,592 in tax to Canberra’s coffers.
The stage 3 tax cuts will deliver some respite to the person on $65,000,but they’ll still end up paying $11,092 in income tax or $1000 more than back in 21-22. Even someone on $100,000 (who received $1200 worth of Lamington) is just $200 ahead of where they were,or about $3.80 a week.
By contrast,a person on $200,000 will pay almost $9100 (or $175 a week) less in tax in 2024-25 than in 2021-22.
Factor in inflation and higher mortgage repayments and you can see the additional financial pain being caused to millions of people. Those are the millions Albanese’s tax changes will benefit most.
There are already complaints from the Liberal Party and its fellow ideological fellow travellers about Albanese engaging in a “class war” by the planned tax changes. Of course,that ignores the class aspect that was always at the heart of the stage 3 cuts (which the end of the Lamington highlighted and was exacerbated by ending the 37 per cent tax rate).
Scott Morrison and the Liberal Party had always hoped to wedge Labor through the stage 3 cuts. Labor swallowed its pride and voted with the government while always hoping to find a way to change them.
Cut through the noise of federal politics with news,views and expert analysis from Jacqueline Maley. Subscribers can sign up to our weekly Inside Politics newsletterhere.