This was the irony of the headline last Saturday when Dutton went public with his climate stance. “Dutton puts a target on ALP’s back,” said the front page ofThe Weekend Australian. In truth,the opposition leader made himself a target. Yes,the government is accountable for its climate policy,but Dutton became the story.
The teal independents mobilised,in a sure sign they see it as a winner in holding the blue-ribbon seats they have won from the Liberals. MPs such as Monique Ryan in Kooyong,Allegra Spender in Wentworth and Zoe Daniel in Goldstein wanted to talk about it because it takes them back to the policy that worked for them at the last election.
Loading
The campaign group that backed the teals,Climate 200,says it received more donations in the days after Dutton revived the climate fight. The group’s convener,Simon Holmes a Court,says it funded 23 campaigns at the last election and aims to support about 30 at the next. “We’re not trying to build a mass teal movement,we are supporting the growing community independents movement,” he says. Some will identify as teal,many will not.
So the essential calculation is whether Dutton has gained ground in key electorates with his new approach on climate. It may work in the Labor electorates he wants to win,such as Gilmore on the NSW South Coast,Dobell and Robertson on the NSW Central Coast,Blair in Queensland and Corangamite in Victoria. Perhaps it helps the Liberals in the West Australian seats they lost to Labor at the last election.
What the policy does not do,however,is win back the voters who fled to the crossbench. It does not win back Goldstein or Kooyong in Melbourne,nor Mackellar,North Sydney,Warringah or Wentworth in Sydney. It will not dislodge Helen Haines in Indi.
Loading
And it can make the Liberal campaigns far more difficult in other urban seats – such as Menzies in Melbourne,held by Keith Wolahan for the Liberals but now more marginal under the draft redistribution. The same applies to Deakin,held by Michael Sukkar and a clear target for Labor. Elsewhere in Melbourne,the Liberals lost Aston last year and failed to recover Dunkley earlier this year. They need to recover those seats and win back Chisholm,also,but their climate policy is a potential barrier.
While the calculations in Sydney depend on the NSW redistribution,it is hard to see the climate policy helping to defeat Labor in Reid,in the inner west,or in Bennelong,across the harbour. And what of Macquarie,held by Labor after one of the tightest contests at the last election? Voters in the Blue Mountains are unlikely to rally to Dutton’s new message.
One of the Liberal Party’s proven winners,Bridget Archer,the first MP in two decades to hold the Tasmanian seat of Bass for more than one term,says in public what others will only admit in private about the 2030 stance. “I don’t know what seats we are hoping to win with that position,” she says.
This explains why some Liberals see the climate policy as a sign of Dutton’s two-term strategy to retake power. The Coalition has 55 seats,Labor has 78,and Dutton needs 21 seats to form majority government. If Dutton aspires to winning power at the next election,he needs a more compelling plan to defeat the teals in Sydney and Melbourne and regain city seats at Labor’s expense. There was no sign of that plan this week.
Loading
Instead,the new approach to climate looks like a way to cement Dutton’s hold on conservative supporters and protect his position as Liberal leader,while going after Labor in key seats. In other words,to push Albanese into minority government at the coming election in the hope of driving him out of power at the next.
In this scenario,Dutton would force Albanese to rely on the crossbench during the next term of parliament,so the Liberals could blame the teals for keeping the left in office. Dutton would survive six years as leader to have a second attempt at the prime minister’s job in 2028. This is not merely press gallery conjecture. It is a theory within the Liberal Party,although it raises a huge question:how would the Liberals charge to victory in 2028 if they are left with a wasteland in metropolitan Sydney and Melbourne in 2025?
Some Liberals talk of a two-term strategy because everyone can see the mountain ahead of Dutton. We may look back at this week as a point where he lost his footing on the climb.